Dine-In Experience
Full-service restaurant dining with fusion Mexican-Italian cuisine in a beautifully decorated space.
- Attentive table service
- Spacious dining room
- Carefully curated atmosphere
⭐ 4.4 (437 reviews)
Visibility score: 87 out of 100MEXITALY is a fusion restaurant in Caguas known for its unique blend of Mexican and Italian cuisine, with quesadilla birria being a customer favorite. While praised for its beautiful decor and attentive service, the restaurant receives mixed feedback on food authenticity and pricing, with many customers appreciating the atmosphere and specialty drinks like piña coladas.
Based on 437 customer reviews
Address: Carr. 172 Prontito Mall Local 1, Caguas, 00725, Puerto Rico
Phone: (787) 949-6607
Hours: Friday 11:00 AM – 11:30 PM, Monday Closed, Sunday 11:00 AM – 11:30 PM, Tuesday 11:00 AM – 10:30 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 11:30 PM, Thursday 11:00 AM – 11:30 PM, Wednesday 11:00 AM – 10:30 PM
Parking: Free parking available on-site
Peak times: Friday-Saturday evenings 6-9pm, Sunday lunch 12-3pm
Nearby neighborhoods: Turabo, Bairoa, Caguas Pueblo
Nearby landmarks: Near Plaza Palmer, Close to Universidad del Turabo, Downtown Caguas area
Full-service restaurant dining with fusion Mexican-Italian cuisine in a beautifully decorated space.
Specialty items like quesadilla birria and fusion entrees that blend Mexican and Italian flavors.
Complete bar menu featuring tropical cocktails, beers, and specialty drinks.
Accommodating larger parties and special occasions in a welcoming environment.
⭐ 4.4 out of 5
437 total reviews
Rating holding steady at 4.4 stars over last 6 months. 23 new reviews this month.
“I highly recommed for this restaurant. The food is so deliciouso The place is so perfect. And the server also is so fablous Mr.adriam”
— Ireen Derodar“Food is really good Loved the vibe of the place My favourite - pinacolada”
— Harika Penukonda“Really want to like this place, I live right down the street in Turabo. Obvious that a lot of time went into the decor. The server was lovely. But the food, like all 'Mexican' food in Caguas, was not even close to Mexican. I don't know why folks here in town call food Mexican. I had a chicken burrito- shredded chicken in a flour tortilla with a sazón taste. Mexican burritos are really easy to make at a restaurant, very basic. I'm definitely not a picky guy but Mexican food isn't the least bit like Puerto Rican food. The chips were those multi colored things and they were cold and stale. Damn...I so want to support you guys. Maybe look up some basic Mexican recipes and try them. Food in Caguas is almost always altered to suit Puerto Rican tradition which means it's starchy, fatty, and pretty much flavorless and free of vegetables. Be awesome to see you folks do something different. I'll be back soon, hoping the first time was just a bad night”
— M“Been there a number of times to order the quesadilla birria. The food is good and the service is good but every time the quesadilla comes without nearly enough consumé, we always run out halfway through. Tonight I asked for a little extra, they charge 19$ for the quesadilla, give nowhere near enough consumé, and they had the gumption to charge an additional $3.95. I feel nickel and dimed and frustrated as a repeat customer, I won't be going back specifically because of this. Paying $19 for a quesadilla birria Is enough, it should come with enough consumé to dip every bite. Not half of what's necessary.”
— John HaddenWe offer a unique fusion of Mexican and Italian flavors, creating distinctive dishes you won't find elsewhere in Caguas.
Our signature quesadilla birria is a grilled tortilla filled with tender birria meat, served with consommé for dipping - it's our most requested dish.
Yes, we have a full bar featuring tropical cocktails, with our piña coladas being especially popular among guests.
Absolutely! Our spacious dining room and attentive service make us perfect for group dining and special celebrations.
Besides our famous quesadilla birria, customers love our fusion chicken dishes, steaks, and our signature piña coladas.
Status: Open now
Peak hours: Friday-Saturday 6-9pm
Kitchen hours: Daily 11am-10pm
Popular this month: Quesadilla birria, Piña coladas
⭐ 4 (901) · 3.1 miles
Calle 1, Caguas
⭐ 4.1 (1527) · 0.9 miles
Puerto Rico 34, Caguas
⭐ 4 (1934) · 2.1 miles
Las Catalinas Mall, Puerto Rico 196 Carr. 196, Caguas
⭐ 4.6 (1502) · 2.1 miles
Ave. Mercado esq, Carr. 1, Calle Luis Munoz Rivera, Caguas
⭐ 4.6 (458) · 1.9 miles
Las Catalinas Cinemas Mall, Puerto Rico 52, Caguas
⭐ 4.2 (485) · 3.3 miles
urb res bairoa, Avenida las Américas BW 3, Caguas
How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.
This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.
MEXITALY manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.
MEXITALY is part of the Buzza local business network.
Browse more restaurants & food on Buzza →